From the video
These numbers come from each company's Canadian pricing page, rechecked on October 30. Square: a $69 reader, 2.5% on in-person credit cards, and 0.75% + 7¢ on Interac debit. No monthly fee for basic point of sale. SumUp: the Go terminal is $125 on sale, regularly $249. 2.50% on credit, 0.90% on debit, and no monthly cost. Shopify POS runs on a Shopify plan. Basic is $49 a month, with 2.6% on in-person cards. Right now the page shows a 3-day free trial, then $1 a month for 3 months. All 3 take tap, chip, Apple Pay and Google Pay. For the shopper at your table, they feel the same. The differences are on your side of the counter. Start with a $40 credit card sale. Square takes $1.00, so you keep $39.00. SumUp also takes $1.00. Shopify takes $1.04, so you keep $38.96.
Square, SumUp and Shopify POS are the three card readers Canadian market vendors compare most, and for a weekend craft fair any of them will take tap, chip, Apple Pay and Google Pay. The differences that matter are the reader price, the fee on Interac debit (which many Canadian shoppers tap), whether you need a phone, and whether your online shop is already on Shopify. All prices below are CAD from each company’s Canadian pages, first checked October 7, 2026 and rechecked October 30, 2026 (Square’s instant-transfer fee is now listed at 1.95%; the other rates were unchanged).
For the selling side, see the holiday market vendor guide, a holiday Etsy or craft-market shop and starting an Etsy shop. Booth gear is covered in craft market booth gear.
How do Square, SumUp and Shopify POS compare in Canada?
The in-person credit card rates are close; Interac debit pricing, hardware cost, and the monthly plan are where they differ.
| Option | Best for | Pricing | In Canada | Pros | Cons |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Square | Most market, craft-fair and mobile-service sellers starting out | Reader $69; 2.5% credit in person; Interac 0.75% + 7¢; no monthly fee for basic POS (source) | Canadian rates; +1.5% on cards issued outside Canada; next-business-day deposits included |
|
|
| SumUp | Sellers who want a standalone terminal that doesn't rely on their phone | Go reader $125 (sale; regularly $249); $0 monthly; 2.50% credit; 0.90% debit (source) | Canadian pricing; Go has free unlimited 4G via a built-in SIM |
|
|
| Shopify POS | Sellers who already run an online Shopify store | Basic $49 CAD/month; 2.6% in person; POS Pro add-on $119/month per location (source) | Canadian plans in CAD; reader hardware priced in Shopify's store |
|
|
Prices and features from each company's own pages, checked October 30, 2026. They change often; confirm on the official site before you buy.
Which card reader is cheapest for a weekend market in Canada?
For low volume, Square usually costs least up front because the reader is $69 and there is no monthly plan for basic point of sale. SumUp’s Go costs more to buy but has no monthly fee and its own data connection. Shopify POS adds a $49 CAD monthly plan, which only makes sense when you also sell online.
Illustrative example
Assumed numbers for one market day with no tax, to show the arithmetic using the listed rates: 20 sales of $40, half on credit and half on Interac debit.
- Square: credit 10 × ($40 × 2.5%) = $10.00; debit 10 × ($40 × 0.75% + $0.07) = $3.70. Total fees about $13.70.
- SumUp: credit 10 × ($40 × 2.50%) = $10.00; debit 10 × ($40 × 0.90%) = $3.60. Total fees about $13.60.
- Shopify Basic: credit 10 × ($40 × 2.6%) = $10.40; debit fees depend on Shopify’s Interac rate in your plan (check the pricing page), plus the monthly plan.
On these assumptions the per-day fees are within a few cents of each other, so the hardware price, the monthly plan and how you like to work decide it. This is a teaching sketch, not a quote.
How much of a $40 sale do you actually keep?
On a $40 in-person sale you keep about $39 on credit with any of the three, and a little more on Interac debit. The arithmetic below uses only the listed Canadian rates (rechecked October 30, 2026); it ignores GST/HST and any monthly plan.
| $40 sale, in person | Square | SumUp | Shopify POS Basic |
|---|---|---|---|
| Credit card fee | $40 × 2.5% = $1.00 | $40 × 2.50% = $1.00 | $40 × 2.6% = $1.04 |
| You keep (credit) | $39.00 | $39.00 | $38.96 |
| Interac debit fee | $40 × 0.75% + $0.07 = $0.37 | $40 × 0.90% = $0.36 | Not shown on the pricing page |
| You keep (debit) | $39.63 | $39.64 | Check Shopify’s rate |
| Card issued outside Canada | $40 × (2.5% + 1.5%) = $1.60, keep $38.40 | Check SumUp’s terms | Check Shopify’s terms |
When is Square’s debit fee cheaper than SumUp’s?
Square’s debit fee has a fixed 7¢, so it costs more on small sales and less on big ones. The two fees are equal when 0.75% × sale + $0.07 = 0.90% × sale, which works out to a sale of about $46.67. Below that, SumUp’s debit fee is lower; above it, Square’s is lower. On a $10 debit sale, Square charges about 14.5¢ and SumUp 9¢, so SumUp saves about 5.5¢ a sale. At that gap it would take roughly 1,000 small debit sales to earn back the $56 difference in reader price (illustrative arithmetic, not a forecast).
What would each cost in the first year?
Fees per sale are close, so the first-year total is decided by hardware and any monthly plan. The rates below were rechecked on each company’s Canadian page on October 30, 2026: Square’s reader at $69 with 2.5% on credit and 0.75% + 7¢ on Interac (Square reader); SumUp’s Go at $125 (listed down from $249) with $0 monthly, 2.50% credit and 0.90% debit (SumUp pricing); Shopify POS Basic at $49 CAD a month with 2.6% in person, and an offer of a 3-day free trial, then $1/month for three months (Shopify POS pricing).
Illustrative example: $2,000 a month in card sales
Assumed: $2,000 of card sales every month, half credit and half Interac debit, average sale $40 (so 25 debit sales a month). Sourced: the rates above.
| Square | SumUp | Shopify POS Basic | |
|---|---|---|---|
| Credit fees per month | $1,000 × 2.5% = $25.00 | $1,000 × 2.50% = $25.00 | $1,000 × 2.6% = $26.00 |
| Debit fees per month | $1,000 × 0.75% + 25 × $0.07 = $9.25 | $1,000 × 0.90% = $9.00 | Not shown on the pricing page |
| Card fees for 12 months | $411.00 | $408.00 | $312.00 + Interac fees |
| Hardware | $69 | $125 | See Shopify’s hardware store |
| Plan for 12 months | $0 | $0 | 3 × $1 + 9 × $49 = $444 |
| Year-one total | $480.00 | $533.00 | $756.00 + Interac fees + reader |
At this volume Square and SumUp are about $50 apart, almost all of it the hardware price. Shopify POS only pays off if you already use Shopify for an online store and want one inventory.
What happens if the market Wi-Fi or cell signal drops?
Outdoor and church-hall markets often have weak signal, so check each reader’s offline rules before the first busy Saturday. Square’s Canadian offline payments page (read October 22, 2026) says:
- Offline payments must be turned on in your settings in advance. The same processing fees apply.
- On a phone paired with a Square Reader (2nd generation), an offline session lasts 24 hours, and pending payments must be uploaded within 72 hours or they expire and can’t be recovered.
- Interac debit, Tap to Pay, and manually entered cards don’t work offline. A shopper with only a debit card will be asked for another card or cash.
- You don’t hear about a decline until you’re back online, and declined or disputed offline payments are your loss.
Illustrative example
Assumed numbers, not a forecast: you take 20 offline credit sales averaging $25 at a market with no signal. That’s 20 × $25 = $500 waiting to upload. If one $25 card later declines, you keep $475 of it before fees.
Before the market, check SumUp’s and Shopify POS’s own help pages for their offline rules, and bring a cash float either way.
The caveat: hardware sale prices and intro offers expire
SumUp’s $125 reader price was still shown as a sale against $249 on October 30, 2026, and Shopify’s $1/month offer is an introductory promotion; both can end without notice. Square says it may offer custom pricing to businesses processing $250K+ in credit card sales, which most market sellers won’t reach. Recheck each page before buying.
Who should pick Square, SumUp or Shopify POS?
| If you… | Lean toward | Why |
|---|---|---|
| Are testing your first few markets | Square Reader | $69 reader, no monthly plan for basic POS |
| Sell where your phone signal or battery is unreliable | SumUp Go | Standalone terminal with built-in 4G |
| Already sell online on Shopify | Shopify POS | Shared inventory and reporting |
| Also take bookings or invoices (detailing, lessons) | Square | Appointments and invoices in one account |
Cash still matters at many markets. Bring a float and a cash box, and a backup way to take payment if the reader fails.
What mistakes do market sellers make with card readers?
- Not testing the reader before the market. Charge a small amount to yourself the week before.
- Ignoring non-Canadian cards. Square adds 1.5% on cards issued outside Canada; tourists’ cards cost more.
- Paying for a monthly POS plan in the off-season. Pause or downgrade when markets end.
- Pricing without fees. Round prices so a 2.5% fee does not eat your margin.
- Forgetting GST/HST. Once registered, set tax in the POS so receipts show it.
Which tax rules apply to card sales at Canadian markets?
Card and cash sales are both business income for income tax, and processor fees are generally deductible business expenses. Your total sales from all channels count toward the GST/HST $30,000 small-supplier threshold. Payment processors may report sales information to tax authorities; see tax on reselling and gig apps. This is not tax, legal, or insurance advice.
Which guides sit next to the card reader comparison?
Read the holiday market vendor guide, Etsy vs Shopify and craft market booth gear. Service businesses that take payment on site can also compare Jobber vs Housecall Pro vs Square Appointments.
What are the common questions?
How much does Square charge per transaction in Canada?
Square's Canadian fee page listed 2.5% for in-person credit cards, 0.75% + 7 cents for Interac debit, 3.3% + 15 cents for manually keyed cards and 2.8% + 30 cents for online and invoice payments on October 7, 2026, with an extra 1.5% on cards issued outside Canada. Instant transfers were listed at 1.95% on October 30, 2026.
What does SumUp cost in Canada?
SumUp's Canadian page listed the Go card reader at $125 (a sale price, regularly $249) with no monthly cost, 2.50% for credit cards and 0.90% for debit cards on October 7, 2026.
Do I need Shopify to use Shopify POS?
Yes. Shopify POS runs on a Shopify plan. Basic was listed at $49 CAD a month with in-person card rates from 2.6%, and POS Pro is an extra $119 CAD a month per location.
Is Square or SumUp cheaper for Interac debit?
It depends on the sale size. Square's listed debit fee is 0.75% + 7 cents and SumUp's is 0.90%, so they match at about a $46.67 sale. SumUp is cheaper on smaller debit sales and Square on larger ones (arithmetic from rates listed October 30, 2026).
Which card reader works without a phone?
SumUp's Go is a standalone terminal with built-in 4G connectivity, according to SumUp. Square's basic Reader pairs with a phone or tablet running the Square app.
Are card processing fees tax deductible?
Processing fees on business sales are generally deductible business expenses on Form T2125. Keep the monthly fee statements. This is general information, not tax advice.
Which sources support this guide?
The rules, rates, and platform requirements in this guide are checked against these primary sources. Retail price ranges are labelled as ranges to verify locally, and they are not quotes.
- Process offline payments — Square
- Square fees in Canada — Square
- Square Reader (Canada) — Square
- SumUp payment processing pricing (Canada) — SumUp
- SumUp Go card reader (Canada) — SumUp
- Shopify POS pricing (Canada) — Shopify
- When to register for and start charging the GST/HST — Canada Revenue Agency
- Square Reader (contactless and chip) — Square
